Free games like Crying Pony

Below are 8 free-to-play Steam games similar to Crying Pony, ranked by player overlap and content similarity. No purchase or Steam login required to view the list. Every pick is a full free-to-play title — not a demo, trial, or time-limited giveaway. imho.run's catalogue refreshes daily, so newly free or newly popular titles surface here without manual editing.

Want the full alternatives list (paid + free + Steam Deck + cheaper picks)? See the parent games like Crying Pony page.

1
Ultimate Custom Night
Free-to-play alternative to Crying Pony — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie with Crying Pony.
Welcome to the ultimate FNAF mashup, featuring 50 selectable characters and custom difficulties!
2018ActionIndieFree To PlayFreeFree to playSimilar games →
2
ENA: Dream BBQ
Free-to-play alternative to Crying Pony — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Crying Pony.
Experience surreal environments and inexplicable characters as ENA in a new wild world.
2025IndieAdventureFreeDeck VerifiedFree to playSimilar games →
3
Indigo Park: Chapter 1
Free-to-play alternative to Crying Pony — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Crying Pony.
Explore the abandoned childhood wonder of Indigo Park! Guided by Rambley the Raccoon, help restore power to the destroyed amusement park while you run from the reason it shut down.
2024ActionIndieAdventureFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
4
The Looker
Free-to-play alternative to Crying Pony — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie with Crying Pony.
You wake up, alone, on a strangely familiar island full of puzzles that will frustrate and annoy you.
2022IndieFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
5
Sheepy: A Short Adventure
Free-to-play alternative to Crying Pony — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Crying Pony.
A Short Handcrafted Pixel Art Platformer that follows Sheepy, an abandoned plushy brought to life. Sheepy: A Short Adventure is the first short game from MrSuicideSheep.
2024IndieAdventureFree To PlayFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
6
Grimm's Hollow
Free-to-play alternative to Crying Pony — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Crying Pony.
A spooky, freeware RPG where you search the afterlife for your brother. Reap ghosts with your scythe, explore haunted caves, and eat ghostly treats on your journey through death.
2019IndieAdventureRPGFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
7
UNBEATABLE [white label]
Free-to-play alternative to Crying Pony — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Crying Pony.
A young girl learns a song. An exclusive side-story set in the world of D-CELL GAMES' upcoming rhythm-adventure.
2021ActionIndieAdventureFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
8
Dagon: by H. P. Lovecraft
Free-to-play alternative to Crying Pony — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Crying Pony.
Face unspeakable horrors. Succumb to madness. Welcome to a free daemonic narrative experience inspired by H. P. Lovecraft.
2021IndieAdventureFree To PlayFreeDeck VerifiedFree to playSimilar games →

Ranked picks