Free games like Mystery Island:Missing Amy

Below are 8 free-to-play Steam games similar to Mystery Island:Missing Amy, ranked by player overlap and content similarity. No purchase or Steam login required to view the list. Every pick is a full free-to-play title — not a demo, trial, or time-limited giveaway. imho.run's catalogue refreshes daily, so newly free or newly popular titles surface here without manual editing.

Want the full alternatives list (paid + free + Steam Deck + cheaper picks)? See the parent games like Mystery Island:Missing Amy page.

1
Doki Doki Literature Club!
Free-to-play alternative to Mystery Island:Missing Amy — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie with Mystery Island:Missing Amy.
The Literature Club is full of cute girls! Will you write the way into their heart? This game is not suitable for children or those who are easily disturbed.
2017IndieFree To PlayCasualFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
2
Helltaker
Free-to-play alternative to Mystery Island:Missing Amy — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Mystery Island:Missing Amy.
Helltaker is a short game about sharply dressed demon girls.
2020IndieAdventureFree To PlayFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
3
The Murder of Sonic the Hedgehog
Free-to-play alternative to Mystery Island:Missing Amy — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie with Mystery Island:Missing Amy.
Sonic the Hedgehog...was murdered!? Get to the bottom of the mystery in this brand-new adventure!
2023IndieSimulationFree To PlayFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
4
The Looker
Free-to-play alternative to Mystery Island:Missing Amy — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie with Mystery Island:Missing Amy.
You wake up, alone, on a strangely familiar island full of puzzles that will frustrate and annoy you.
2022IndieFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
5
Sheepy: A Short Adventure
Free-to-play alternative to Mystery Island:Missing Amy — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Mystery Island:Missing Amy.
A Short Handcrafted Pixel Art Platformer that follows Sheepy, an abandoned plushy brought to life. Sheepy: A Short Adventure is the first short game from MrSuicideSheep.
2024IndieAdventureFree To PlayFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
6
Travellin Cats in Paris
Free-to-play alternative to Mystery Island:Missing Amy — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie with Mystery Island:Missing Amy.
Find 100 cats hidden in Paris, France in this cute hand-drawn hidden object game by Travellin Cats - the original viral hidden cat game creator!
2023IndieFree To PlayCasualFreeDeck VerifiedFree to playSimilar games →
7
UNBEATABLE [white label]
Free-to-play alternative to Mystery Island:Missing Amy — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Mystery Island:Missing Amy.
A young girl learns a song. An exclusive side-story set in the world of D-CELL GAMES' upcoming rhythm-adventure.
2021ActionIndieAdventureFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →
8
Eternal Senia
Free-to-play alternative to Mystery Island:Missing Amy — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie with Mystery Island:Missing Amy.
Thoughts and expectations ARPG
2015ActionIndieRPGFreeDeck PlayableFree to playSimilar games →

Ranked picks