Games like The Mystery of Oak Island
If The Mystery of Oak Island is your kind of game, the closest matches are Telling Lies, The Blackwell Legacy and Frog Detective 1: The Haunted Island — picked from the ranked list below. Each pick is ranked by what players of this game also play, shared genres and tags, and review-mined similarity — not a generic popularity list.
Get personalized picks →About The Mystery of Oak Island: A gripping point-and-click adventure – inspired by the real treasure hunt on Oak Island in Nova Scotia, Canada. Unravel a web of murder, myth, and forgotten history. Some secrets are better left buried.
Players who liked The Mystery of Oak Island also play
Steam players who put hours into The Mystery of Oak Island also tend to own these titles — a signal called collaborative filtering. imho.run cross-references millions of library ownership patterns to surface games whose real audiences overlap, regardless of whether their genre tags match.
Telling Lies
WHY THIS
Top pick for The Mystery of Oak Island fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
Four private lives. One big lie. Search through secretly recorded video conversations to discover the truth. The successor to the acclaimed Her Story.
The Blackwell Legacy
WHY THIS
Second-strongest match for The Mystery of Oak Island fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
When 3 NYU students kill themselves, nobody thinks that a sinister force is at work. Nobody but fledgling medium Rosa Blackwell & her new spirit guide Joey Mallone.
Frog Detective 1: The Haunted Island
WHY THIS
Third-strongest match for The Mystery of Oak Island fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
You're a detective, and a frog, and it's time to solve a mystery.
Thimbleweed Park™
WHY THIS
Ranked #4 for The Mystery of Oak Island fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
In Thimbleweed Park, a dead body is the least of your problems. Switch between five playable characters to uncover the surreal secrets of this strange town in a modern mystery adventure game from the creators of Monkey Island and Maniac Mansion. The deeper you go, the weirder it gets.
Nancy Drew®: Legend of the Crystal Skull
WHY THIS
Ranked #5 for The Mystery of Oak Island fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
The Search is on for an Unearthly Artifact in New Orleans!
Unavowed
WHY THIS
Ranked #6 for The Mystery of Oak Island fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
A demon has possessed you and used your body to tear a swath of bloodshed through New York. You are now free, but life as you knew it is over. Your only path forward is joining the Unavowed - an ancient society dedicated to stopping evil. No matter what the cost.
The Excavation of Hob's Barrow
WHY THIS
Ranked #7 for The Mystery of Oak Island fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
The Excavation of Hob's Barrow is a folk horror narrative-driven adventure. Explore the isolated moors of rural Victorian England as you uncover the mysteries of Hob's Barrow. The answers lie in the soil...
Kathy Rain 2: Soothsayer
WHY THIS
Ranked #8 for The Mystery of Oak Island fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
In this point-and-click urban thriller, down-and-out private eye Kathy Rain will embark on her most dangerous case yet — the pursuit of the notorious serial killer known as the Soothsayer. Find clues, gather evidence, connect the dots, and confront the murderer before the hunter becomes the hunted…
Free alternatives
Free-to-play games that recommended players of this title also tend to enjoy.
Doki Doki Literature Club!
WHY THIS
Free-to-play pick from the same recommendation pool — no purchase to try it. Shares Indie with The Mystery of Oak Island.
The Literature Club is full of cute girls! Will you write the way into their heart? This game is not suitable for children or those who are easily disturbed.
Life is Strange - Episode 1
WHY THIS
Free-to-play pick from the same recommendation pool — no purchase to try it. Shares Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
Episode 1 now FREE! Life is Strange is an award-winning and critically acclaimed episodic adventure game that allows the player to rewind time and affect the past, present and future.
Ultimate Custom Night
WHY THIS
Free-to-play pick from the same recommendation pool — no purchase to try it. Shares Indie with The Mystery of Oak Island.
Welcome to the ultimate FNAF mashup, featuring 50 selectable characters and custom difficulties!
Bongo Cat
WHY THIS
Free-to-play pick from the same recommendation pool — no purchase to try it. Shares Indie with The Mystery of Oak Island.
Bongo cat needs your help. Bongo cat needz more hatz!!! Every time you press a key, Bongo cat will punch your taskbar. Type, click, play, work to collect more points. Which hats will you find?
ENA: Dream BBQ
WHY THIS
Free-to-play pick from the same recommendation pool — no purchase to try it. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
Experience surreal environments and inexplicable characters as ENA in a new wild world.
The Murder of Sonic the Hedgehog
WHY THIS
Free-to-play pick from the same recommendation pool — no purchase to try it. Shares Indie with The Mystery of Oak Island.
Sonic the Hedgehog...was murdered!? Get to the bottom of the mystery in this brand-new adventure!
Indigo Park: Chapter 1
WHY THIS
Free-to-play pick from the same recommendation pool — no purchase to try it. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
Explore the abandoned childhood wonder of Indigo Park! Guided by Rambley the Raccoon, help restore power to the destroyed amusement park while you run from the reason it shut down.
Narrow it down
Head-to-head comparisons
Plays great on Steam Deck
Valve-Verified or Playable picks from the similar pool — ready to go on Deck out of the box.
The Blackwell Legacy
WHY THIS
Deck Verified — runs on Steam Deck out of the box. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
When 3 NYU students kill themselves, nobody thinks that a sinister force is at work. Nobody but fledgling medium Rosa Blackwell & her new spirit guide Joey Mallone.
Frog Detective 1: The Haunted Island
WHY THIS
Deck Verified — runs on Steam Deck out of the box. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
You're a detective, and a frog, and it's time to solve a mystery.
Thimbleweed Park™
WHY THIS
Deck Verified — runs on Steam Deck out of the box. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
In Thimbleweed Park, a dead body is the least of your problems. Switch between five playable characters to uncover the surreal secrets of this strange town in a modern mystery adventure game from the creators of Monkey Island and Maniac Mansion. The deeper you go, the weirder it gets.
Unavowed
WHY THIS
Deck Verified — runs on Steam Deck out of the box. Shares Indie and Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
A demon has possessed you and used your body to tear a swath of bloodshed through New York. You are now free, but life as you knew it is over. Your only path forward is joining the Unavowed - an ancient society dedicated to stopping evil. No matter what the cost.
The Excavation of Hob's Barrow
WHY THIS
Deck Verified — runs on Steam Deck out of the box. Shares Adventure with The Mystery of Oak Island.
The Excavation of Hob's Barrow is a folk horror narrative-driven adventure. Explore the isolated moors of rural Victorian England as you uncover the mysteries of Hob's Barrow. The answers lie in the soil...
Frequently asked about The Mystery of Oak Island
- What games are most similar to The Mystery of Oak Island?
- Based on Steam play patterns and shared genres/tags, the games most often recommended alongside The Mystery of Oak Island are Telling Lies, The Blackwell Legacy, Frog Detective 1: The Haunted Island.
- Who developed The Mystery of Oak Island?
- The Mystery of Oak Island was developed by Visionaire Studio UG.
imho.run ranks Steam game alternatives using a mix of collaborative filtering (ALS / iALS / EASE / LightGCN), content scoring over genres, categories, Steam tags, developers, and publishers, plus AI-extracted vibes mined from review text. The page above is generated in seed mode anchored on The Mystery of Oak Island.
For library-aware picks tuned to your specific taste, sign in with Steam on the home page.