Games like Polly's Puzzle Box
Below are 13 hand-picked alternatives to Polly's Puzzle Box for fans of indie, adventure, ranked by imho.run's hybrid recommender. Each pick is scored on three signals: collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries (which players who logged hours in Polly's Puzzle Box also play), content overlap on genres, categories, and storefront tags, and review-mined "vibe" embeddings that catch tonal similarity even when the genre label differs. Sections below cover closest matches, reviewer cross-mentions, and Steam Deck–friendly options. No login required — these picks work anchor-only.
About Polly's Puzzle Box: As a small flea, explore a mysterious puzzle box filled with shapes and secrets. Gather strange items with hidden abilities, and unravel a trail of clues as you attempt to escape.
Players who liked Polly's Puzzle Box also play
Ranked by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries plus content overlap on genres, tags, and developers.
- 1
Dungeon Gals
Top pick for Polly's Puzzle Box fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
A small crisis control team has been summoned to help a civilization in the sky escape impending doom! Explore dungeons, solve puzzles, and find lots of treasure to help prepare yourself for incredible challenges!
- 2
Echoes of the Unread
Second-strongest match for Polly's Puzzle Box fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
Wake up in a world where stories come to life. In this enchanted 8-bit musical adventure, use the power of song to explore whimsical book-inspired realms, solve puzzles, and help Rhapsody find her way home from a library that doesn't want to let her go.
- 3
Gravity Grove
Third-strongest match for Polly's Puzzle Box fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
Gravity Grove is a 2D platformer set on the faces of a 3D cube. Walk over the edges to rotate the entire level, shifting gravity in your favor to open up new paths and uncover hidden secrets from the past.
- 4
ANIMAL WELL
Ranked #4 for Polly's Puzzle Box fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
Explore a dense, interconnected labyrinth, and unravel its many secrets. Collect items to manipulate your environment in surprising and meaningful ways. Encounter beautiful and unsettling creatures, as you attempt to survive what lurks in the dark. There is more than what you see.
- 5
- 6
Crypt Custodian
Ranked #6 for Polly's Puzzle Box fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
Crypt Custodian is a charming metroidvania about cleaning up the afterlife. Play as Pluto - a mischievous cat who has died, and is sentenced to be the afterworld's janitor... FOREVER! Hang out with other doomed ghosts, battle beasts, and explore a vastly expansive landscape.
- 7
Constance
Ranked #7 for Polly's Puzzle Box fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
Constance is a 2D hand-drawn action adventure featuring a paintbrush-wielding artist, striving to escape from a colorful but decaying inner-world, created by her declining mental health.
- 8
Isles of Sea and Sky
Ranked #8 for Polly's Puzzle Box fans by collaborative filtering across millions of Steam libraries. Shares Indie and Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
A fantastic, oceanic, open world puzzle adventure. Solve innovative block puzzles while unearthing a mystifying story, gaining new friends that change the puzzle landscape, and unlocking powers that provide more options for how you choose to progress through the enigmatic Isles of Sea and Sky.
Narrow it down
Head-to-head comparisons
Plays great on Steam Deck
Valve-Verified or Playable picks from the similar pool — ready to go on Deck out of the box.
- 1
Dungeon Gals
Deck Verified — runs on Steam Deck out of the box. Shares Indie and Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
A small crisis control team has been summoned to help a civilization in the sky escape impending doom! Explore dungeons, solve puzzles, and find lots of treasure to help prepare yourself for incredible challenges!
- 2
ANIMAL WELL
Deck Verified — runs on Steam Deck out of the box. Shares Indie and Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
Explore a dense, interconnected labyrinth, and unravel its many secrets. Collect items to manipulate your environment in surprising and meaningful ways. Encounter beautiful and unsettling creatures, as you attempt to survive what lurks in the dark. There is more than what you see.
- 3
- 4
Constance
Deck Verified — runs on Steam Deck out of the box. Shares Indie and Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
Constance is a 2D hand-drawn action adventure featuring a paintbrush-wielding artist, striving to escape from a colorful but decaying inner-world, created by her declining mental health.
- 5
Isles of Sea and Sky
Deck Verified — runs on Steam Deck out of the box. Shares Indie and Adventure with Polly's Puzzle Box.
A fantastic, oceanic, open world puzzle adventure. Solve innovative block puzzles while unearthing a mystifying story, gaining new friends that change the puzzle landscape, and unlocking powers that provide more options for how you choose to progress through the enigmatic Isles of Sea and Sky.
Frequently asked about Polly's Puzzle Box
- What games are most similar to Polly's Puzzle Box?
- Based on Steam play patterns and shared genres/tags, the games most often recommended alongside Polly's Puzzle Box are Dungeon Gals, Echoes of the Unread, Gravity Grove.
- Who developed Polly's Puzzle Box?
- Polly's Puzzle Box was developed by Box Penguin Games.
imho.run ranks Steam game alternatives using a mix of collaborative filtering (ALS / iALS / EASE / LightGCN), content scoring over genres, categories, Steam tags, developers, and publishers, plus AI-extracted vibes mined from review text. The page above is generated in seed mode anchored on Polly's Puzzle Box.
For library-aware picks tuned to your specific taste, sign in with Steam on the home page.