imho.run
Menu

Games like Island of Penance

  • 14 games
  • Updated May 5, 2026

Players who liked Island of Penance also play

The closest matches to Island of Penance: Tina: Swordswoman of the Scarlet Prison, Sheryl ~The Alchemist of the Island Ruins~, Slave's Sword 2, Ideology in Friction, and Noelle Does Her Best!. Ranked by imho.run from Steam co-play data, shared tags and reviews.

  1. Rank 03

    Why this

    Also RPGMaker and JRPG, like Island of Penance.

    • $14.99 (Price checked Nov 14)
    • Deck Playable
    • 2019
  1. Rank 07

    Pray Game

    • $24.99 (Price checked Nov 14)
    • 2023

The full ranked list: top 24 games like Island of Penance

Best match first, as plain text. The same list for AI assistants:
  1. 1
    Tina: Swordswoman of the Scarlet Prison

    Also RPGMaker and NSFW, like Island of Penance.

    • 83% of 75 reviews
  2. 2
    Sheryl ~The Alchemist of the Island Ruins~

    Genres: RPG

    • 88% of 50 reviews
  3. 3
    Slave's Sword 2

    Also RPGMaker and JRPG, like Island of Penance.

    • 80% of 51 reviews
  4. 4
    Ideology in Friction

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 83% of 239 reviews
  5. 5
    Noelle Does Her Best!

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 71% of 62 reviews
  6. 6
    The Heiress

    Genres: Indie, Adventure, RPG

    • 71% of 180 reviews
  7. 7
    Pray Game

    Genres: Indie, Adventure, RPG

    • 94% of 54 reviews
  8. 8
    Princess Project

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 79% of 75 reviews
  9. 9
    The Curse of Kubel

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 64% of 107 reviews
  10. 10
    Demons Roots

    Genres: Indie, Adventure, RPG

    • 95% of 593 reviews
  11. 11
    Ruins Seeker

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 93% of 126 reviews
  12. 12
    Elise the Devil

    Genres: Indie, Adventure, RPG

    • 87% of 173 reviews
  13. 13
    Killing Time

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 68% of 161 reviews
  14. 14
    Lilitales

    Also NSFW and JRPG, like Island of Penance.

    • 81% of 67 reviews
  15. 15
    Seed of Evil

    Genres: Indie, Adventure, RPG

    • 83% of 64 reviews
  16. 16
    Detective Girl of the Steam City

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 91% of 222 reviews
  17. 17
    Terrible Laboratory

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 78% of 72 reviews
  18. 18
    Dark Hero Party

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 60% of 68 reviews
  19. 19
    Alternate DiMansion Diary

    Genres: Indie, Adventure, RPG

    • 86% of 140 reviews
  20. 20
    The Scarlet Demonslayer

    Genres: Indie, Adventure, RPG

    • 78% of 60 reviews
  21. 21
    Succubus Rem

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 87% of 115 reviews
  22. 22
    AZURA

    Genres: Strategy, Indie, Adventure

    • 65% of 116 reviews
  23. 23
    Liz ~The Tower and the Grimoire~

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 83% of 75 reviews
  24. 24
    Saint Emiliana

    Genres: Indie, RPG

    • 81% of 52 reviews
Island of Penance — Steam game cover
  • Released: 2024
  • Developer: ONEONE1
  • Price: $10.39−20%checked Nov 2
  • Steam Deck: Deck Playable
  • 33% of 27 reviews
  • Genres: Indie, Adventure, RPG
  • Platforms: Windows

Players highlight

  • Body horror powers the protagonist
  • Hyper specific niche appeal
  • Kafkaesque absurdity in storytelling
  • Bleak
  • Dark
  • Mysterious

More games like Island of Penance, sliced differently

More from ONEONE1

Other recommendable Steam games by ONEONE1, ranked by review count so the studio's hits land first.

About Island of Penance

The closest matches to Island of Penance: Tina: Swordswoman of the Scarlet Prison, Sheryl ~The Alchemist of the Island Ruins~, Slave's Sword 2, Ideology in Friction, and Noelle Does Her Best!. Ranked by imho.run from Steam co-play data, shared tags and reviews.

If Island of Penance is your kind of game, the closest matches are Tina: Swordswoman of the Scarlet Prison, Sheryl ~The Alchemist of the Island Ruins~ and Slave's Sword 2 — picked from the ranked list below. Reviewers describe it as bleak, dark and mysterious, and single out its body horror power system and narrative branching through abuse. Each pick is ranked by what players of this game also play, shared genres and tags, and review-mined similarity — not a generic popularity list.

About Island of Penance: Having doubts about her father's "accidental" death, Illumina begins to look deeper into the reports. The information leads her on a journey to become a prison guard on a notorious prison island. There she must contend with felons and corrupt officials to uncover the truth.

Is Island of Penance worth buying?

Too few reviews to call

A summary of what players say, not a promise you'll like it. Every signal is listed below.

  • Only 27 Steam reviews so far, not enough to judge.
  • On sale: 20% off, now $10.39 (checked Nov 2).
  • Steam Deck Playable: works, with some rough edges.

What fans praise · Themes mined from positive reviews

Top critical reviews

The most up-voted negative English reviews in our sample, quoted as written.

“It's a pretty brutal, no choice given type of game, seriously just wait until it hits the $5 mark so you don't feel cheated.”
4 h played
“It is an ok game. The story is way to linear for my liking, and the lewds are not the best. It is a bit confusing about where to go and what to do next, but there is a guide here on Steam in foreign language with images that points to the…”
2 h played
More negative reviews on Steam ↗

People who play it also play: Tina: Swordswoman of the Scarlet Prison, Sheryl ~The Alchemist of the Island Ruins~, Slave's Sword 2

How this verdict works →

Frequently asked about Island of Penance

Can I run it?

Does Island of Penance run on Steam Deck?

Island of Penance is rated Playable on Steam Deck — it runs, but expect some manual adjustments (control remapping, text size, or graphics settings) for the best experience.

How much does Island of Penance cost?

Island of Penance is listed on Steam at 10.39 USD (current store price; Steam sales may reduce this temporarily).

What games are most similar to Island of Penance?

Based on Steam play patterns and shared genres/tags, the games most often recommended alongside Island of Penance are Tina: Swordswoman of the Scarlet Prison, Sheryl ~The Alchemist of the Island Ruins~, Slave's Sword 2.

Who developed Island of Penance?

Island of Penance was developed by ONEONE1 and published by Kagura Games.