Games like Lily's Well

The closest matches to Lily's Well: Static Dread: The Lighthouse, Yuppie Psycho: Executive Edition, House, Pathologic 3, and Subliminal. Ranked by imho.run from Steam co-play data, shared tags and reviews.

If Lily's Well is your kind of game, the closest matches are Static Dread: The Lighthouse, Yuppie Psycho: Executive Edition and House — picked from the ranked list below. Reviewers describe it as atmospheric, contemplative and mysterious, and single out its item collection and multiple endings. Each pick is ranked by what players of this game also play, shared genres and tags, and review-mined similarity — not a generic popularity list.

PureIceBlue's 2022 free-to-play horror adventure drops players into a rainy spring night in 2005, where a child named Lily must descend into a mysterious well to rescue someone calling for help. Players gather items and solve puzzles while making text-based decisions that branch toward multiple endings. Reviewers describe the 8-bit pixel art as atmospheric and unsettling, with dark psychological details woven beneath the retro aesthetic. The challenging short experience has earned a 98% positive rating from over 1,600 Steam reviews, with players highlighting how slow-burn horror escalates with each death and how story twists recontextualize every playthrough. Emotional payoffs reward repeated exploration across branching paths, with multiple endings encouraging replay. The game runs verified on Steam Deck and is designed for short bursts of play.

About Lily's Well: It is a rainy night in the Spring of 2005. Lily is left home alone after her Papa put her to bed. She is awoken by a cry for help outside her window. It is coming from the well. Help Lily gather rope to go down the well and save the poor soul trapped down there.