IMHO.

Single-player games like That Which Was Lost

Below are 13 single-player Steam games similar to That Which Was Lost, ranked by player overlap. Every pick carries Steam's Single-player category, so multiplayer-only titles or always-online games don't sneak in. imho.run pulls the category data from Steam directly — Single-player here matches what the store labels.

Want the full alternatives list (paid + free + Steam Deck + cheaper picks)? See the parent games like That Which Was Lost page.

Ranked picks

  1. 1
    Knights of Fate — Steam game cover

    Knights of Fate

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares Indie and RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    The Triskelion Knights are an elite force selected and trained to protect the country. They're the King's right hand and they are now called to the biggest mission of their lives, to stop a Shaman from regaining his full powers and starting another war for the souls of the people.

    2022IndieRPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  2. 2
    Clan Duramont — Steam game cover

    Clan Duramont

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares Indie and RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    Join the Clan Duramont.and journey into an adventure of family, courage, betrayal and redemption in this classic 2D RPG worth about 15-20 hours of playtime.

    2025IndieRPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  3. 3
    Heavy Lies the Crown — Steam game cover

    Heavy Lies the Crown

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    Blessed with a sharp mind and sharp blades, Triath will be called to leadership in the resistance against the invasion... That is when his past catches up with him.

    2022RPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  4. 4
    Knightess — Steam game cover

    Knightess

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares Indie and RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    Anastasia, Artemisia & Lozen, three mercenaries who roam the Kingdom' looking for work, are seen by the King as the possible solution to keep the peace, even if only temporally. Join the three of them, as they journey in what will become a path of discovery, friendship and betrayal.

    2024IndieAdventureRPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  5. 5
    From Within — Steam game cover

    From Within

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares Indie and RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    Delve into a fantastic old-school RPG featuring great characters and an exciting storyline, from the makers of Skyfall and Ashes of Immortality.

    2022IndieRPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  6. 6
    The Oathkeeper — Steam game cover

    The Oathkeeper

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares Indie and RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    Ira is a famed mercenary, called The Oathkeeper. When one of his contracts puts him in the middle of an ancient war of good v. evil and face to face with the woman he begins to fall in love with, he will have to start fighting for more than just money!

    2022IndieRPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  7. 7
    Against All Odds — Steam game cover

    Against All Odds

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    Of Arawn is asked something much greater than what he is prepared to give... that's when his true journey begins.

    2023RPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  8. 8
    Reborn Souls — Steam game cover

    Reborn Souls

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares Indie and RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    As a Maiden of the Ecclesia, Sabrina is in charge of special assignments, in lands where dark magic, urban legends and folkore are all real. While investigating a new incident in one of the appeased villages, she will learn much more than she bargained for...

    2022IndieRPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  9. 9
    Ultima Adventum — Steam game cover

    Ultima Adventum

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares Indie and RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    It lies upon the shoulders of Alana and other three Arises, fated individuals, to stop the plague that is to come. Through the darkest dungeons and longest journeys, they must build the courage and power to save their world.

    2021IndieRPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  10. 10
    The Stone of God — Steam game cover

    The Stone of God

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares Indie and RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    Dei Lapis is a legendary stone, said to have been created by the creator of the universe. The stone carries his power of ultimate creation and for generations it has been the object of pursuit of many who wished to use it's power, some for good, some for evil.

    2021IndieRPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  11. 11
    Hymns of Resurrection — Steam game cover

    Hymns of Resurrection

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares Indie and RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    Calder and Ygritte are the King's elite soldiers. They come upon Karandir and the Occultists' wicked plans and become the ones responsible for preventing an evil resurrection and a new war.

    2022IndieRPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  12. 12
    Shadows of the Night — Steam game cover

    Shadows of the Night

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    There is a war coming. Pallas joined the Fortress out of his sense of duty towards protecting his country and most importantly to him, his family, and will soon realize that to truly protect them he will have to abandon it all.

    2023RPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →
  13. 13
    Knights of the Throne — Steam game cover

    Knights of the Throne

    Single-player alternative to That Which Was Lost — playable solo, no multiplayer required. Shares Indie and RPG with That Which Was Lost.

    Lasha is the leader of the Knights, a young woman of honor and strength. Deadly with a blade and pure in her heart, she will volunteer to take on a perilous path to protect the kingdom from an army of enemies never seen before.

    2023IndieRPG9.99 USDSingle-playerSimilar games →