imho.run
Menu

Games like Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition

  • 23 games
  • Updated May 4, 2026

Players who liked Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition also play

The closest matches to Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition: Dark Heritage: Guardians of Hope, Fairy Tale Mysteries: The Puppet Thief, Abyss: The Wraiths of Eden, ASYLUM, and Nightmares from the Deep: The Cursed Heart. Ranked by imho.run from Steam co-play data, shared tags and reviews.

  1. Rank 03

    Why this

    Same atmospheric mood as Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition.

    • $14.99 (Price checked Nov 7)
    • Deck Playable
    • 2014
  1. Rank 04

    ASYLUM

    • $24.99 (Price checked Nov 6)
    • Deck Verified
    • 2025
  2. Rank 06

    Hope Lake

    • $7.99 (Price checked Nov 7)
    • 2016

The full ranked list: top 24 games like Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition

Best match first, as plain text. The same list for AI assistants:
  1. 1
    Dark Heritage: Guardians of Hope

    Shares fast travel map with Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition.

    • 58% of 59 reviews
  2. 2
    Fairy Tale Mysteries: The Puppet Thief

    Shares journal tracking with Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition.

    • 80% of 83 reviews
  3. 3
    Abyss: The Wraiths of Eden

    Same atmospheric mood as Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition.

    • 92% of 388 reviews
  4. 4
    ASYLUM

    Genres: Indie, Adventure

    • 84% of 254 reviews
  5. 5
    Nightmares from the Deep: The Cursed Heart

    Genres: Adventure, Casual

    • 90% of 368 reviews
  6. 6
    Hope Lake

    Genres: Indie, Adventure, Casual

    • 65% of 252 reviews
  7. 7
    Ghost Encounters: Deadwood - Collector's Edition

    Genres: Adventure, Casual

    • 51% of 80 reviews
  8. 8
    The Last Door - Collector's Edition

    Genres: Indie, Adventure

    • 94% of 968 reviews
  9. 9
    Call of the Sea

    Genres: Indie, Adventure, Casual

    • 87% of 2,379 reviews
  10. 10
    Foolish Mortals

    Genres: Adventure

    • 95% of 368 reviews
  11. 11
    Rusty Lake Hotel

    Genres: Indie, Adventure

    • 94% of 2,019 reviews
  12. 12
    Observation

    Genres: Indie, Adventure

    • 79% of 2,478 reviews
  13. 13
    Queen's Quest: Tower of Darkness

    Genres: Adventure, Casual

    • 64% of 99 reviews
  14. 14
    Questerium: Sinister Trinity HD Collector's Edition

    Genres: Adventure, Casual

    • 78% of 101 reviews
  15. 15
    Nancy Drew®: Legend of the Crystal Skull

    Genres: Adventure

    • 90% of 192 reviews
  16. 16
    Stormhill Mystery: Family Shadows

    Also Lovecraftian and Hidden Object, like Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition.

    • 77% of 97 reviews
  17. 17
    Gray Matter

    Genres: Adventure, Casual

    • 91% of 351 reviews
  18. 18
    Subsurface Circular

    Genres: Indie, Adventure, Casual

    • 95% of 1,353 reviews
  19. 19
    Mysteries of the Undead

    Genres: Adventure, Casual

    • 66% of 73 reviews
  20. 20
    Transient: Extended Edition

    Also Lovecraftian and Conversation, like Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition.

    • 65% of 150 reviews
  21. 21
    Whispering Willows

    Genres: Indie, Adventure

    • 81% of 474 reviews
  22. 22
    Left in the Dark: No One on Board

    Genres: Adventure, Casual

    • 81% of 248 reviews
  23. 23
    Kathy Rain 2: Soothsayer

    Genres: Indie, Adventure

    • 96% of 829 reviews
  24. 24
    The Dark Rites of Arkham

    Genres: Adventure

    • 97% of 276 reviews
Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition — Steam game cover
  • Released: 2014
  • Developer: Gunnar Games
  • Price: $7.99checked Nov 2
  • 83% of 47 reviews
  • Genres: Adventure
  • Platforms: Windows

Players highlight

  • Difficulty settings adjust hotspot visibility and hint refresh rates
  • Lovecraftian atmosphere with a talking octopus entity
  • Morphing collectibles reveal missed items in bonus challenges
  • Atmospheric
  • Challenging
  • Eerie

More games like Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition, sliced differently

About Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition

The closest matches to Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition: Dark Heritage: Guardians of Hope, Fairy Tale Mysteries: The Puppet Thief, Abyss: The Wraiths of Eden, ASYLUM, and Nightmares from the Deep: The Cursed Heart. Ranked by imho.run from Steam co-play data, shared tags and reviews.

If Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition is your kind of game, the closest matches are Dark Heritage: Guardians of Hope, Fairy Tale Mysteries: The Puppet Thief and Abyss: The Wraiths of Eden — picked from the ranked list below. Reviewers describe it as atmospheric, challenging and eerie, and single out its bonus challenge mode and difficulty adjustable hotspots. Each pick is ranked by what players of this game also play, shared genres and tags, and review-mined similarity — not a generic popularity list.

About Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition: Save your twin brother from the sinister sea menace that overtakes everything and everyone on the troubled island of Pilgrim's Hook.

Is Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition worth buying?

Too few reviews to call

A summary of what players say, not a promise you'll like it. Every signal is listed below.

  • Only 47 Steam reviews so far, not enough to judge.
  • Price: $7.99 (checked Nov 2).
  • People who recommend it had played a median of 5 h when they wrote their review.

What fans praise · Themes mined from positive reviews

Top critical reviews

The most up-voted negative English reviews in our sample, quoted as written.

“I bought this game with sinister bundle super offer as it comes as a part of it. I love hidden object games but this is not good, the only valuable thing is the hidden object part which are well made, but all the rest... The story would…”
4 h played
More negative reviews on Steam ↗

People who play it also play: Dark Heritage: Guardians of Hope, Fairy Tale Mysteries: The Puppet Thief, Abyss: The Wraiths of Eden

How this verdict works →

Frequently asked about Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition

Can I run it?

How much does Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition cost?

Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition is listed on Steam at 7.99 USD (current store price; Steam sales may reduce this temporarily).

What games are most similar to Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition?

Based on Steam play patterns and shared genres/tags, the games most often recommended alongside Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition are Dark Heritage: Guardians of Hope, Fairy Tale Mysteries: The Puppet Thief, Abyss: The Wraiths of Eden.

Who developed Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition?

Small Town Terrors: Pilgrim's Hook Collector's Edition was developed by Gunnar Games.