Free games like Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven
Below are 8 free-to-play Steam games similar to Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven, ranked by player overlap and content similarity. No purchase or Steam login required to view the list. Every pick is a full free-to-play title — not a demo, trial, or time-limited giveaway. imho.run's catalogue refreshes daily, so newly free or newly popular titles surface here without manual editing.
Want the full alternatives list (paid + free + Steam Deck + cheaper picks)? See the parent games like Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven page.
Ranked picks
- 1

Scarlet Hollow — Episode 1
Free-to-play alternative to Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven.
The free-to-play first episode of a horror-mystery game with dark humor and hand-drawn art by Black Tabby Games. Note — we are retiring this store page. While the build here is still up-to-date, please download the DEMO from the main Scarlet Hollow store page. Thank you and have fun!
- 2

Trapped with Jester
Free-to-play alternative to Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven.
An unusual horror-themed Visual Novel about waking up in a carriage with a stranger… Whatever could go wrong?
- 3

The Test: Secrets of the Soul
Free-to-play alternative to Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven.
You will answer a series of questions that will reveal things from deep within. Some will be uncomfortable, but with great knowledge comes great sacrifice. Can you make it all the way through The Test, and are you SURE you want the answers you seek? For it is time to unlock "Secrets of the Soul..."
- 4

Our Life: Beginnings & Always
Free-to-play alternative to Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Casual with Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven.
A twenty-dollar bill, four summers, fifteen years, and a one of a kind life. Create an experience that’s all your own in this near-fully customizable visual novel where you grow from childhood to adulthood with the lonely boy next door.
- 5

Emily is Away
Free-to-play alternative to Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven.
Emily is Away is an interactive story. Create a screenname and choose your path through the branching narrative.
- 6

Dagon: by H. P. Lovecraft
Free-to-play alternative to Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie and Adventure with Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven.
Face unspeakable horrors. Succumb to madness. Welcome to a free daemonic narrative experience inspired by H. P. Lovecraft.
- 7

A Date in the Park
Free-to-play alternative to Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven — no purchase or trial window. Shares Adventure with Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven.
A short and mysterious free point and click adventure game, inspired by the feeling of oddness in an everyday situation.
- 8

Killer Chat! - Original Edition
Free-to-play alternative to Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven — no purchase or trial window. Shares Indie with Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven.
Killer Chat! is a satirical serial killer dating chatsim. Play as a (customisable!) writer as you pretend to be a serial killer, get inspiration for your book, fall in love and try not to call the cops through a whirlwind six months with your murderous beau of choice. What could possibly go wrong?